Triggers – 6

It almost goes without saying that America’s foreign enemies would try to capitalize on attempts by its domestic enemies to undermine the country. The primacy of the individual in our system is anathema to the Chinese Communist Party, the World Economic Forum, the One-Worlders, and Islam in general. An outright alliance (albeit temporary) with the Left is easy to predict. And as in the example of our CW I, different nations would back different factions.

China is already in a war with us. This week’s declassification by President Trump of more election interference intelligence only hints at the scope of that war. An internal conflict here would be immediately capitalized upon by China.

Triggers – 5

While in most of the world a proliferation of firearms would be a trigger, in the US, it may act more as a stabilizing influence – it is much harder to massacre a well-armed populace. However, organized militias and lone actors radicalized online raise the risk of tit-for-tat attacks. Incidents like political assassinations or attacks on infrastructure could spiral if perceived as justified “self-defense” by factions. Surveys show a minority, but non-trivial, percentage of the Left view violence as sometimes justified for political goals. The recent spate of often successful attacks on their political opponents confirms that position.

Political violence is now a fact of life in the US. It is often noted that the Left uses it on a sliding scale, while the Right views it as an On/Off switch. I’d wager that a successful assassination of President Trump would be THE On switch for the Right to finally unleash en masse. And, once started, that would be difficult to turn off.

Triggers – 4

For sure, this is the one that worries me. Conflicts over issues like illegal immigration, 2d Amendment restrictions, abortions or drug laws could lead to states defying federal authority (or vice versa). This might involve National Guard deployments, sanctuary policies, or nullification-style resistance.
If a state creates laws against ICE agent masking, in clear violation of federal law, what happens? Does local law enforcement start trying to arrest federal officers? Does a governor attempt to mobilize the state National Guard against the feds? Sounds a lot like a Fort Sumpter moment.

Triggers – 3

I think economic stress is more an underlying foundation than a trigger for strife. Certainly, a sudden crash could exacerbate things, but the perception of great inequality (Tax The Billionaires!) lays a groundwork for other dissatisfactions. The Left always presents this as class warfare but, in reality, unfettered immigration is a huge driver. The pressure on housing has led to sky high rents and great difficulty in youth access to home purchasing. The downward pressure on wages from illegals working for significantly under market and under the table, makes job seeking particularly difficult for our entry level citizens.
The Trump recovery, job on-shoring, and US energy production may put this in the background, so long as the benefits make their way down to the lowest levels.

Triggering Factors – 2

There are clearly deep partisan divides in this country on issues like election integrity, immigration, abortion, guns, race/cultural identity, and economic policy. Many of them are “yes or no” issues on which compromise is impossible. Likewise, when parties align more around group identity than policy, and when each side views the other as an existential threat, compromise becomes nearly impossible. Social media amplifies the differences.

At the same time, social media, the internet and AI have broken the lock that traditional media had on gatekeeping the news and deciding what is accepted as fact. The now-obvious prior control of “the narrative” has resulted in a deep loss of trust in news reporting and trust in the government that propagates its narrative through the media.

Triggering Factors – 1

Our country can be seen as one with weakening institutions and loss of faith in government in general. With the 2020 Presidential election fraud now being shown as fact and not a conspiracy theory, people’s trust in the electoral process has greatly eroded. The fact that democrats are en masse refusing to clean up elections with the SAVE Act, indicates that their ideas will not win elections, so they have to cheat to gain or retain power.

Another disputed presidential election involving widespread claims of fraud, more lawfare and legal battles, or refusal to concede, could spark widespread protests turning violent. Flashpoints might include attempts to disrupt certification, state-federal clashes over vote counting, or targeted political violence such as assassinations of officials or candidates.

CW II, by the numbers

The American war dead numbers got me thinking about civil war. According to long-standing historical estimates, our American Civil War killed about 620,000 Union and Confederate soldiers. With the US population from the 1860 census at 31,443,321, that represented about 2% of the population. So, if an American Civil War II kicked off, with a current population of about 343 million people, an equivalent 2% death toll would be almost 7 million.There are 33 states with 7 million or fewer people. 7 of those are right around that number. Indiana, for example, is 7.01 million. There’s some context. Even more – that would be about 14 times our World War II losses. 
Now, there are a bunch of assumptions and errors built into that comparison. Perhaps a more recent example? Spain’s civil war in 1936 – 1939 had about 500,000 war dead with a population of 25 million population. Huh. 2%. Maybe this is a thing? But that would be a doctoral research thesis.